The Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL) has set aside Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission’s (APERC) orders that restricted payments for wind power generated beyond the prescribed Capacity Utilisation Factor (CUF), directing distribution companies to pay generators the applicable generic tariff for all electricity supplied under the relevant Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), along with applicable interest.
In its judgment dated 17 November 2026, delivered in a batch of appeals, the tribunal overturned the provision allowing payment of just ₹0.50 per unit for electricity generated beyond the normative CUF benchmark. It also set aside the mechanism for calculating CUF cumulatively at the end of each year.
The dispute involved multiple wind power generators and Andhra Pradesh distribution utilities, including Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh Limited (APSPDCL). The affected generators included Beta Wind Farm Private Limited, Danu Wind Parks, Mytrah Vayu, Hetero Wind Power and Axis Wind Farms. Separately, JSW Energy confirmed that four of its subsidiaries had secured relief under the same judgment: JSW Vayu (Tungabhadra), JSW Vayu (Indravati), JSW Wind Power (Pennar) and JSW Wind Power Limited.
How the tariff dispute began
The dispute centred on the interpretation of normative CUF, a benchmark used by regulators to determine the generic tariff for wind power projects. Under APERC’s 15 November 2012 tariff order, eligible wind projects entering into PPAs between 15 November 2012 and 31 March 2015 were assigned a preferential levelised tariff of ₹4.70 per unit for 25 years, calculated using a normative CUF of 23%.
The issue arose when generators produced more electricity than the annual generation corresponding to this benchmark. APSPDCL argued that the generic tariff was applicable only up to the normative CUF and that excess generation should receive different commercial treatment. APERC subsequently allowed payment of ₹0.50 per unit for such additional electricity, subject to cumulative CUF calculations. Wind power generators challenged this approach, arguing that their PPAs provided for payment for all delivered electricity at the agreed tariff.
Why APTEL overturned the reduced payment mechanism
In its assessment, APTEL examined the relevant PPA provisions governing delivered energy, electricity purchase and payment obligations. The tribunal found that these provisions did not distinguish between electricity generated within the normative CUF and electricity supplied beyond it.
It held that normative CUF was a parameter used for tariff determination and could not be converted into an additional contractual restriction on the quantity of electricity eligible for payment. The tribunal also observed that wind generation varies with weather conditions and that treating an annual benchmark as a payment ceiling was not supported by the contractual provisions examined in the appeals.
Consequently, APTEL set aside APERC’s directions on cumulative CUF calculations and the ₹0.50-per-unit rate. It clarified that no fresh tariff determination or remand to the state regulator was required for the disputes covered by the judgment. The distribution companies were directed to release the withheld amounts with applicable interest under the respective PPAs.
Orient Green Power estimates ₹12.98 crore recovery
The ruling has direct financial implications for affected renewable energy producers. Orient Green Power Company Limited announced that its material subsidiary, Beta Wind Farm Private Limited, is entitled to recover approximately ₹12.98 crore, including withheld principal and interest, following the judgment.
The dispute relates to Beta’s 50.4 MW wind power project in Andhra Pradesh, commissioned on 27 July 2013 under a 25-year PPA with APSPDCL at ₹4.70 per unit. The company stated that APSPDCL had withheld ₹5.93 crore for 12.62 million units of electricity supplied between July 2016 and July 2017, treating the generation beyond the 23% normative CUF as ineligible for the full tariff.
According to Orient Green Power’s stock-exchange disclosure, the estimated recovery comprises ₹5.93 crore in withheld principal and ₹7.05 crore in interest calculated up to 31 October 2026. The company said actual cash-flow benefits will depend on implementation of the order and receipt of the outstanding amount.
JSW Energy has also confirmed the favourable outcome for its four subsidiaries but has not disclosed the amount recoverable by them. The judgment therefore provides tariff-related relief to multiple wind power generators, although the financial implications will vary according to individual project PPAs and outstanding claims.
The ruling reinforces the importance of contractual tariff provisions in renewable energy procurement. By clarifying that the normative CUF cannot be treated as a payment ceiling under the PPAs considered, APTEL has addressed a long-standing commercial issue affecting wind power generators in Andhra Pradesh.





