Karnataka’s Transport Minister Ramalinga Reddy has raised serious concerns regarding the safety and operational effectiveness of electric buses in Bengaluru run by the Gross Cost Contract (GCC) model. In a letter to Union Minister of Heavy Industries H. D. Kumaraswamy, Reddy has stated that the safety of electric buses operated privately needs to be reassessed, as they pose a threat not only to the smooth operation of the public transport system but also to the safety of the passengers as well.
Performance and Safety Concerns Being Assessed:
- Reddy’s concerns stemmed from a review of private operators who manage electric buses associated with the central government’s FAME II and Convergence Energy Services Limited (CESL) schemes. Both of these federal government schemes seek to promote electric mobility in India through the facilitation of electric transport for the private sector.
- The Karnataka Transport Department data indicate that electric buses are involved in more accidents than diesel buses. Diesel buses have an accident rate of 0.05 accidents per lakh kilometers as compared to 0.07 for electric buses. thus raising concerns about safety and oversight of operations.
Call for a Review of Policy and Operations:
- Reddy highlighted the need for a thorough performance audit of the current operators along with a review of their compliance with their contractual obligations. He requested that the Ministry of Heavy Industries revamp its monitoring.
- The transportation experts and industry insiders noted increasing concerns around the reliability of electric buses, particularly in high-demand cities like Bengaluru. While the shift to electric mobility is essential for India’s net-zero aspirations, experts noted that implementation and operational readiness are crucial.
“Deploying electric buses is just one part of the challenge. Ensuring effective driver training, maintenance protocols, and reliable service is essential for long-term success,” said an energy policy expert familiar with the FAME II scheme.
Cases of intermittent service breakdown have been observed, and commuters have also reported delays as a result of technical failure and inadequate powering facilities. The e-bus system has also been tested by Bengaluru’s heavy traffic and climate, which has elevated the durability and efficiency of the e-bus system.
India Electric Mobility Goals Implications
The security issues expressed by the Transport Minister in Karnataka are very timely because India is increasing its electric buses through central and state mobility programs. The GCC model, where buses are operated privately with the government paying per kilometer, has hastened the introduction, but the issue of accountability and monitoring is still a concern.
Unless these concerns are mitigated, the development of India towards its 2030 electric mobility objectives, especially in public transport, may be stalled. Analysts believe that this state of affairs can lead to other states reconsidering their e-bus operation and standards of service.
Follow-Up and Government Intervention
In response to the letter that Reddy has prepared, the ministry of heavy industry should carry out a policy review and also seek the input of the major stakeholders in this case, including CESL, state transport undertakings (STUs), and the private fleet operators.
Future FAME III bids will probably have some increased performance standards, better certification of drivers, and penalties against service failures. The proactive attitude of Karnataka might be used as a model by other states to enhance the regulatory regimes of electric public transport.
Electrify your feed! Click here to join our Whatsapp group and to get the latest updates, expert insights, and innovations driving India’s energy storage revolution.
